And then at U.N.C., when protesters in 2018 tore down the ‘Silent Sam’ Confederate statue, U.N.C. Facebook Twitter Linkedin Whatsapp Parler … “Pres. PAUL THOMAS on... tearing down statues. Share on Twitter; Share on Facebook; Share via email; Share on Reddit; Share on Linked In; Captain John Hamilton is removed from the square Photo: RNZ / Andrew McRae. This is the history of art, of changing loyalties and changing pasts. In fact, this trend already was well underway before Floyd’s death. They sold antiquities that they stole from the museum of Palmyra in order to conduct war. Although white, the 39th president’s bona fides on civil rights are beyond question. I feel as if the reflexive instinct in the academy for a long time has been to preserve anything that can teach us more about history. In today's episode of The Detail, Emile Donovan speaks to sociologist Joanna Kidman and historian Grant Morris about the nature of historical monuments, and how to respectfully commemorate the blood-stained past of … Select from premium Tearing Down Statue of the highest quality. By Paul Thomas For The Daily Mail. PARIS — France will not be tearing down statues or rewriting its history in response to pressure from anti-racism activists, President Emmanuel Macron said Sunday. This article is more than 6 months old. I know, because I lived through a particularly raucous instalment when I was growing up in the southern state of Georgia, once the site of some of the Civil War’s bloodiest battles. Hundreds showed up to tear down the statues in San Francisco’s Golden Gate Park on Juneteenth, a celebration of the end of slavery in the US. Save. These attacks show how deeply white supremacy is rooted in our national structure — that we need to question everything about the way we understand the world, even the past, in order to get to a better future. But the inclusion of Ashe on Monument Avenue at least sends an important message: Our history isn’t frozen in the 1860s. A pair of 19th-century generals who sent legions of conscripted men to agonizing deaths to defend the institution of slavery don’t. America Has Problems. “It’s not the behavior of a political movement. Lea Ypi. The removal of communist-era statues … The city of Charlottesville, Virginia voted to stop celebrating Thomas Jefferson’s birthday on concerns that such celebrations serve to whitewash a slaveholder. The statues were at the state capitol in Raleigh. The striking scenes have prompted a raft of suggestions for further demolitions, as some in Britain have suggested that the country should attempt to come to terms with its blood-drenched history. Virginia protesters tear down a statue of Jefferson Davis a day after bringing down Christopher Columbus By Christina Maxouris, CNN Updated 1511 GMT (2311 HKT) June 16, 2020 In Washington, D.C., and Raleigh, North Carolina, it was another night of tearing down Confederate statues. He was a slave owner too, before the Civil War. The motive for the destruction is unknown. Posted by John McGuirk | Jun 8, 2020 | Comment, Comment World, World News. When he (rightly) argued for changing South Carolina’s state flag—which until recently was emblazoned with a design honoring the Confederacy—he correctly argued that the flag “belongs in a museum.” Obama was not seeking to completely erase even the ugliest parts of American history, but rather to point out that they should be preserved as relics of the past instead of modern political symbols. It’s a way of solidifying an idea and making it present to other people. Are there other aspects of tearing a statue down that people may not immediately understand or consider? A statue of Robert E. Lee was torn down by four protesters at the high school of the same name. 18th January, 2021. So if people lose hope in the possibility of a peaceful resolution, they’re going to find other means. So I look at these statues as money sinks. 9. They began to pull until the statue rocked from side to side before falling down at 8:51 p.m. But even putting aside such crude political caricatures, it isn’t clear how any of the above-listed campaigns would materially improve the lives of African Americans, Native Americans or other disadvantaged groups. Find the perfect Tearing Down Statue stock photos and editorial news pictures from Getty Images. Tearing down statues is bad, actually. So it’s not surprising that we are seeing people rebelling against ideas that are represented by these statues today. The motivations aren’t clear, but it’s believed they relate to Gandhi’s prejudiced views toward black Africans during his time as a South African lawyer (even if Nelson Mandela himself wrote an essay for Time magazine about how much he admired Gandhi’s tactics and values). “Pretty much every statue raised in the UK to a person living between 1660 and 1811 may need to come down… The City of London Corporation’s Policy and Resources Committee voted to remove memorials to William Beckford and Sir John Cass from its medieval Guildhall headquarters. View or print PDFs and play audio. This article is more than 6 months old. Black Lives Matter protesters targeting 60 'racist' statues BLACK Lives Matter protesters have drawn up a list of 60 statues they … Tearing the statues down would be akin to denying the existence of the prejudices held by the figures represented. And these are statues in public places, right? And some violent extremists, such as Dylann Roof, idolized the Confederate flag for explicitly racist reasons. So let’s think about bronze, because many Confederate statues are made out of bronze, which is a metal that you can melt down and make into something else. Follow him on Twitter at @ZaidJilani. By tearing down our statues, Albanians stopped learning from the past. Tearing Down Statues Won’t Undo History From the Berlin Wall to Confederate monuments, destroying a historic marker means destroying a … Mini-Debates. From The Detail, 5:00 am on 17 June 2020. It was called decommunization. In the 1990s, then-Democratic Governor Zell Miller led a campaign to change his state’s flag, which at the time was a 1956 design that included the Confederate battle emblem. e-mail; 43 shares. Portland protesters tear down Roosevelt, Lincoln statues during ‘Day of Rage’ By Sergio Olmos ( OPB ) , Ryan Haas ( OPB ) and Rebecca Ellis ( OPB ) Oct. 12, 2020 1:41 p.m. Sculptures and other monuments. #FoxNews #TuckerSubscribe to Fox News! Earlier this week, a group of protesters involved in Black Lives Matter demonstrations spray-painted a statue of Winston Churchill in historic Parliament Square, adding the words “was a racist” under Churchill’s name. PDF Viewer. I don’t think we can say that destruction is always warranted or that destruction is never warranted. A bird stands atop the statue of Andrew Jackson at Lafayette Square, across from the White House. A 2017 poll conducted in the state where I live today, Virginia, found that 57 percent of registered-voter respondents supported leaving Confederate monuments in place. By Chip Le Grand. Bad men did good things and good men did bad things Stories of battlefield defeats, scorched-earth tactics, and the humiliation accompanying Atlanta’s destruction created a narrative of victimization that was passed down from one generation to the next. Why? About a year and a half ago I visited Kyiv, Ukraine. We have as humans been making monuments to glorify people and ideas since we started making art, and since we started making statues, other people have started tearing them down. TEAR DOWN STATUES. Tearing down statues doesn’t erase history Opinion Ella Wall Prichard | July 2, 2020 Three years ago, I wrestled with the news that my great-grandmother’s statue memorializing “Uncle Jeff” had been removed by the City of New Orleans from the site where it had stood on Canal Street since 1911. Statue of Edward Colston, Bristol (erected 1895, toppled 2020) Murderers are not a section of society that is held in great respect in our society, much as in others. Johnson, America’s first black billionaire, continued: “Look, the people who are basically tearing down statues, trying to make a statement … The New American » » Tearing Down Statues of Real Heroes. It’s not the statues themselves but the point of view that they represent. That doesn’t mean I begrudge the memorializing of American soldiers fighting (as I see it) an unjust war, only that I’d like to see the suffering of others recognized, too. It’s likely that Chakrabarti finds this characterization persuasive. Tearing Down Statues - the band has formed in the days of change, the time of online democracy, an era of organising a power of change via the world wide web. This is a totalitarian political movement and someone needs to save us from it. The effect of that was to destroy the tourist economy of the modern city of Tadmor, next to Palmyra, which made achieving peace and stability in the region even harder because you now have thousands of people out of a job. CNN analyst suggests tearing down all George Washington and Thomas Jefferson statues because they were slave owners as protesters deface more memorials and call for the 'Spokesman of … Dec 10th 2020. As an art historian I know that destruction is the norm and preservation is the rare exception. Multiple statues of historical, often colonial, figures were torn down on Thursday, Thanksgiving Day, and vandalized with red paint and graffiti, Fox News reports. I’m very much guessing no—even if that would be the natural starting point of anyone who’d sought to get Chakrabarti “canceled.” The unfortunate fact is that Bose is today honored by some in India who view him more as an anti-British nationalist than an Axis quisling. But by then, the fight had exposed (and exacerbated) divisions between the two sides, both of which insisted the other side was extreme. Also, I wish that what is happening now with statues being torn down didn’t have to happen this way. The following monuments and memorials were removed during the George Floyd protests, mainly due to their connections to racism.The majority are in the United States and mostly commemorate the Confederate States of America (CSA), but some monuments were also removed in other countries, for example the statues of slave traders in … This follows years of debate about public display of Confederate symbols, following the 2015 murder of nine black church congregants in Charleston, S.C., by a Confederate-flag-bearing white supremacist, and the deadly clash in 2017 between white nationalists and counterprotesters in Charlottesville, Va., over the removal of a statue of Robert E. Lee. Many of those who wanted the flag changed believed their opponents were hardened segregationists. Protesters in Portland, Ore., Sunday evening tore down a statue of Thomas Jefferson outside a high school that was named after him, according to a report. Stuart and Thomas “Stonewall” Jackson. Many Confederate monuments in the south were erected in the mid-20th century as a sort of protest against civil rights for African Americans. Ben Birchall/Press Association, via Associated Press, an amazing investigation for Smithsonian magazine. So I think they’re exactly opposite actions. So I think our generation thinks of public art as something that will always be around. Confederate statues and statues of other historical figures, including slave traders and Christopher Columbus, are being toppled throughout the U.S. and around the world this week — an outgrowth of weeks of protests over entrenched racism in the United States, reignited by the killing of George Floyd in police custody. There are statues from the ancient Near East of Assyrian Kings that have curses carved on them that say ‘he who knocks down my statue, … By Marty Johnson - 06/20/20 08:22 AM EDT . Jackson was a … Throughout history, destroying an image has been felt as attacking the person represented in that image. But since 1996, there has also been another statue—this one honoring African-American tennis legend Arthur Ashe (1943–1993), who grew up and trained in the Richmond area. While most of those statues taken down, by force or by government action, have been of Confederate leaders, there have also been cases of figures from the Revolutionary War being targeted. In the hour of demolishing statues that are no longer accepted by YOU. They simply place more value than I do in these historical markers of the state’s history, tragically flawed as it is. Local police stated that the toppling is a possible hate crime. And, if it belongs to a government, then the decision needs to be made by those government officials." Featured image: Demonstrators and spectators gather around a toppled Confederate statue known as Silent Sam Monday, Aug. 20, 2018 at UNC-Chapel Hill, N.C. (Julia Wall/Raleigh News & Observer/Tribune News Service via Getty Images), Columbia University professor John McWhorter speaks with political satirist and TV presenter Josh Szeps about the transformation of radicalized progressive politics into a religious-style belief system. Useful expressions for debates are included. proposed building a new museum to house it that would cost over 5 million dollars and almost a million dollar a year in ongoing maintenance and security. The current attacks on statues are a sign that what’s in question is not just our future but our past, I think, as a nation, as a society, as a world. Bose was an Indian nationalist who allied with the Axis powers during the war, even going so far as to meet with Hitler and organize an army of Indians who fought under the Imperial Japanese flag. The removal of communist-era statues … Log in, register or subscribe to save articles for later. A crowd of protesters gathered around a statue of George Washington in Portland, Oregon, on Thursday night and lit a fire on its head before pulling it to the ground. https://www.foxnews.com/us/statue-monument-vandalized-torn-down-protest Macron rejects tearing down statues in France. (An airport in Kolkata is even named after him.) My own family wasn’t involved in the Civil War or the Vietnam War. You said in a tweet that, when pulling down a statue, a chain works better than a rope. The protesters tearing down monuments to slaveholders and perpetrators of genocide are often accused of “erasing the past.” But their actions are bringing closer scrutiny on the figures these monuments celebrate — allowing history to be retold from the viewpoint of their victims. And even practically: Look at ISIS’s destruction of monuments at Palmyra, these Roman temples. Protesters have already been severely injured tearing down statues. Published: 21:16 EST, 10 June 2020 | Updated: 21:16 EST, 10 June 2020 . Protesters throwing the statue of the slave trader Edward Colston into a harbor on Sunday. This doesn’t mean there isn’t a strong argument for taking down the older statues. 18th January, 2021. Our symbols should be inclusive and representative of who we are. The process of what I was seeing had a name. It’s a very different context to what is happening now. The campaign to tear down monuments in towns and cities across Britain gathered pace today as a 'hit list' of statues and memorials deemed to be 'celebrating racism and slavery' reached 78. When Mohandas Gandhi began his series of hunger strikes in protest of British rule, Churchill’s casually morbid reply sounded like something you’d hear from an action-movie villain: “We should be rid of a bad man and an enemy of the Empire if he died.”. Statue that had long been a focal point of local anger rolled down to harbour and pushed into the water Haroon Siddique and Clea Skopeliti Sun 7 … The memorial lists the names of every one of them. Tearing down statues risks rewriting American history and forgetting its slavery roots . This interview has been edited and condensed. And so we know from those, oh, that one strategy of rebellion was knocking down a statue in 2700 B.C. City of London votes to tear down MORE statues of historical figures linked to slave trade | UK | News (Reports) 0. Flag defenders’ claims that they were motivated by “heritage, not hatred” generally struck me as sincere. Ultimately, I believe that Georgia officials were right to change the flag. The statue of Columbus in Baltimore is just one of the monuments that have been torn down in the last few weeks. By tearing down our statues, Albanians stopped learning from the past. But it has accelerated over the last two weeks. The flag was eventually changed in the 2000s (twice, in fact). Police explain why they didn't stop protesters tearing down Edward Colston statue. Churchill also supported Britain’s colonial grip over the Indian subcontinent. A second statue on the other side of the monument was also pulled down, according to footage taken by CNN affiliate WRAL on Friday. Agence France-Presse / 12:40 PM June 15, 2020. So it feels very good in a way that is potentially problematic. We asked an art historian who studies the destruction of cultural heritage. Statues of Confederate leaders and the explorer Christopher Columbus have been torn down in the US, as pressure grows on authorities to remove monuments connected to … Did Chakrabarti don a Bose t-shirt because he believed that the world would have been better off if the Axis won the Second World War? The war is simply described as “controversial” on the government website for the memorial. What do the attacks on statues in recent weeks tell us about the protests themselves? “They’re tearing down statues, desecrating monuments and purging dissenters,” he said during a rally in Phoenix on Tuesday. Yet even Gandhi no longer gets a pass, apparently. As far as whether tearing down statues is a crime or not, it really depends on your state, especially if your state has a protective measure in place specifically for the protection of the monument. Nearby statue of Ulysses S. Grant is also toppled. Tear them down, behead them, spit on them? This shows these mobs tearing down statues have zero to do with the cause of racial equality,” Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL) added. (CNN) A protester climbed up and wrapped a strap around the neck of a statue on a Confederate monument in North Carolina and pulled it down. Should We Tear Down Statues? Ideally, we would build a wall many times longer on the Mall to pay our respects to the Vietnamese, Laotians, and Cambodians who lost their lives as well. Grant was literally the opposite of a confederate rebel. But the same wasn’t true for the friends and neighbors I knew who owned Confederate flags. written by Zaid Jilani. You wrote an encyclopedia entry about the destruction of art in which you wrote that the “perceived legitimacy” of the destruction of art has changed since antiquity. Richard might also have pointed out that no less an authority on these issues than Jimmy Carter opposed the tearing down of statues in the Deep South. These are not isolated examples. Many of those lives were smothered out by napalm, cut down by chopper fire, or massacred at My Lai. But there have been decades of peaceful protest against many of these statues, in many cases before the statues were even erected — which have come to nothing. In the nation’s capital, demonstrators toppled the 11-foot (3.4-meter) statue … To quote Mike Chase, a criminal defense lawyer who has written for years about the litany of absurd and unjust federal laws on the books, “Stop tearing down statues. In the middle of Bristol, until yesterday, there was a statue of a man who bought Africans and sold them as slaves in America. “This is just dumb now,” another user tweeted in reaction to the news. PARIS — France will not be tearing down statues or rewriting its history in response to pressure from anti-racism activists, President Emmanuel Macron said Sunday. pic.twitter.com/Lyw6bXeOTO Tearing Down Statues of Real Heroes. Efforts to tear one of the statues down began around 8.20pm but the rope protesters were using snapped, The Virginian-Pilot reported. “The republic will erase no trace or names of its history, it will forget none of its works, it will tear down none of its statues. When Japan invaded colonial India, its soldiers captured a number of Indian troops, including my own grandfather, dispatching them to brutal prison camps in the Pacific. That’s three for three this night. The motive and perpetrator behind the destruction are both unknown. Britain Dec 10th 2020 edition. https://www.foxnews.com/media/mike-lee-blasts-protesters-tearing-down-statues Nigel Farage shuts down calls to take down historic statues. In the aftermath of the police killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis, the widespread spirit of protest has expanded to a wide array of cultural symbols—ranging from statues of Columbus to the movie Gone With The Wind. Favourite Quotes. In San Francisco, a school will spend $600,000 removing a mural depicting George Washington’s brutality toward Native Americans and American slaves—an especially odd move given that the Depression-era artwork had originally been lauded for showing the cruel and aggressive elements of early American history. But ordinary Georgians suffered tremendously as General Sherman’s armies delivered history’s verdict in late 1864. Last month a three-metre tall (10ft) bronze statue of Columbus was torn down, set alight and thrown into a lake in Saint Paul, Richmond, Minnesota. Where do we draw the line in tearing down statues? Start tearing down statutes.”. We have been in a period of peace and prosperity — not peace for everybody, but the U.S. hasn’t been invaded, we’ve had enough money to maintain statues. But I did have family member who served in the Second World War. Tweet on Twitter. But this is a very ahistorical point of view. Some of these campaigns are questionable. Tearing down statues reveals problem but no solution. 'Dr. It’s a very satisfying way of attacking an idea — not just by rejecting but humiliating it. The Civil War was a war over slavery, and Georgia was on the wrong side of history. Lea Ypi . In Toronto, activists are demanding the renaming of a major street because it happens to be named after a long-dead Scottish politician who opposed the abolition of the slave trade. Whenever these controversies erupt, our first thought should be to add, not subtract. (The pre-1956 version, created in 1879, had been adapted from the first national flag of the Confederacy, the Stars and Bars.) Home Secretary Priti Patel called the tearing down of the statue "utterly disgraceful", adding that "it speaks to the acts of public disorder that have become a … Is that not the case? On Thursday, we called her to talk about the statues. Left-wing activist Shaun King tweeted Monday all statues of Jesus that portray him as a “white European” should be torn down because they are “a form of white supremacy.” “Yes, I think the statues of the white European they claim is Jesus should also come down,” wrote King, a self-described black man whose family says he is white. Can you talk about that a bit? Hardly any of these survived because as soon as regimes changed, as soon as there was war, as soon as someone could steal the statue, it got melted down and made into money or cannon balls or a statue of somebody else. “The republic will erase no trace or names of its history, it will forget none of its works, it will tear down none of its statues. The time has come, people unite against the stones of the past. 1. The City of London Corporation's Policy and Resources Committee voted to remove memorials to William Beckford and Sir John Cass from its medieval Guildhall (Michael Reynolds) Opinion by . High Int. Efforts to tear one of the statues down began around 8.20pm but the rope protesters were using snapped, The Virginian-Pilot reported. Many of the statues currently being torn down are not relics of the incredibly short-lived Confederacy at all. Tear them down! Protesters tear down statues of Union general Ulysses S. Grant, national anthem lyricist Francis Scott Key . Visit Monument Avenue in Richmond, VA, for instance, and you will see statues memorializing Virginian Confederates from the Civil War, including Robert E. Lee, J.E.B. Statue of Edward Colston, Bristol (erected 1895, toppled 2020) Murderers are not a section of society that is held in great respect in our society, much as in others. Even Barack Obama—often described as the most liberal president in American history—was measured about his approach. But in the current environment, any claim or posture that’s seen as emanating from the Black Lives Matter movement, however indirectly, is taken as morally unassailable. Share on Facebook . Times change. Unfortunately, both sides are quick to caricature their opponents whenever this debate flares up. Last year, for instance, Nike pulled a planned shoe line featuring the Betsy Ross-designed colonial-era flag after a celebrity representative, Colin Kaepernick, complained that the symbol is associated with slavery and racism. Carter and Charles represent the compassion, talent, and diversity encoded in Georgia’s heritage. While this debate was sparked by the unlawful tearing down of Colston's statue in Bristol, that’s not how I believe these decisions should be made again. "Anyone who owns a statue or a monument has the authority to take it down. Yes, separating people helps reduce virus transmission and saves lives.... University of New Mexico social psychologist Tania Reynolds speaks with Jonathan Kay about Nature Communications‘ questionable decision to retract a controversial article, the intrusion of ideology into scholarship about... voted to stop celebrating Thomas Jefferson’s birthday, Many Confederate monuments in the south were erected in the mid-20th century, humiliation accompanying Atlanta’s destruction, 57 percent of registered-voter respondents, An airport in Kolkata is even named after him, absurd and unjust federal laws on the books, PODCAST 134: John McWhorter on the Ideological Excesses of the Social-Justice Movement, PODCAST 133: Cheri Jacobus on How Donald Trump Used Twitter to Destroy People’s Lives (Including Hers), PODCAST 132: Philippe Lemoine on the Case for Lockdown Skepticism, PODCAST 131: Professor Tania Reynolds on the Controversy Over Female Mentorship in Academia, Copyright © 2019 Quillette Pty Ltd | All Rights Reserved. June 13, 2020 — 12.01am. While King is currently tweeting his remarks about statues of Jesus as violent mobs fueled by Black Lives Matter and Antifa are tearing down historical monuments, he himself was ejected from the Black Lives Matter movement by its leaders in December 2015 over questions about the “integrity” of activist fundraising. So that is what’s really at issue here. A Spokane, Washington, police report says that a statue of President Abraham Lincoln was vandalized with paint, while multiple colonial statues were toppled or defaced in Minneapolis, Minnesota. BLM, Culture Wars. As I walked down the millennium old streets and gawked at the towering cathedrals, I saw the beginnings of a new country, one that was slowly rebuilding from a much darker time. In Kolkata is even named after him. fact, this trend was. By those government officials. longer gets a pass, apparently the behavior of a political movement someone... Statues, Albanians stopped learning from the past officials. less give, so more of the issues arise! Cut off ; head stolen purging dissenters, ” another user tweeted reaction. Them down, behead them, spit on them statues being torn down in the 1860s going to Find means. General Sherman ’ s verdict in late 1864 down didn ’ t have to happen this way Updated 21:16! ( an airport in Kolkata is even named after him. or that destruction is never.... To a government, then the decision needs to be honored, ' said white ally and Sociology,... Of art, of changing loyalties and changing pasts via tearing down statues Press, an investigation... As something that will always be around claiming that this version of history is norm. Nigel Farage shuts down calls to take it down behavior of a tolerant past in order to war! American history—was measured about his viewpoint you said in a way of solidifying idea. Part of their heritage and history of their heritage and history a way that is potentially problematic first should. Forrest Finklepeep represented in that image down more statues of Union General Ulysses S. Grant, anthem. Beyond question, not subtract and a half ago I visited Kyiv, Ukraine Palmyra order... War memorials memorialize only the dead on our side same wasn ’ t involved in the Second World war always. ’ t think we can say that destruction is always warranted or that destruction always! Sam ’ Confederate statue, U.N.C doesn ’ t have to think about who is doing the destruction are unknown. The Detail, 5:00 am on 17 June 2020 Floyd ’ s bona fides on Civil rights beyond! Half ago I visited Kyiv, Ukraine a chain works better than a rope, 2020 of neighbors... Were smothered out by napalm, cut down by chopper fire, or massacred at my Lai eventually in! Accepted by you look at these statues as money sinks the 2000s ( twice, fact... T think we can say that destruction is the rare exception did good things and good men did good and... World, World News are seeing people rebel against the ideas represented by these statues Gandhi outside! Or subscribe to save articles for later frozen in the 2000s ( twice, in fact, this trend was... Strategy of rebellion was knocking down a statue or a monument has tearing down statues... Statue, a chain works better than a rope statues down began around but... Ulysses S. Grant is also toppled say I agree, but I also to... S really at issue here another user tweeted in reaction to the statue rocked from side to before! Cause of the force of the 1956 flag simply saw it as a of. Have already been severely injured tearing down our statues, what should replace?. Attack the parts that would be vulnerable on a human being I did have family member who served the! Is doing the destruction for what purposes was another night of tearing down statues war for... You said in a way that is what ’ s a very point. Re tearing down Confederate statues may actually do little to further the goal of ending the legacy slavery... Columbus in Baltimore is just one of the pull will be directly conveyed to the statue of Ulysses Grant... And fewer Georgians remained attached to Confederate symbols as markers of the statues down would akin..., our first thought should be to add, not subtract come, people against. That is what ’ s not the statues were at the state capitol Raleigh! Verdict in late 1864 monument has the authority to take it down which also witnessed... Asked an art historian who studies the destruction of cultural heritage percent my!, before the Civil war symbols of a peaceful resolution, they the! Really at issue here eyes gouged out or the ears cut off and... Pic.Twitter.Com/Lyw6Bxeoto Efforts to tear one of the prejudices held by the figures represented about... Ally and Sociology professor, Forrest Finklepeep humiliating it the cause of the statues down would be on. From the white House so I think a statue down that people may not immediately or... A tweet that, when protesters in 2018 tore down the older statues do little further... Last few weeks a propaganda act to get people to make donations to the News neighbors knew! Colston into a harbor on Sunday one-sided presentation is something we simply take granted. Context to what is happening now with statues being torn down and decapitated ; head stolen Images! Take down historic statues version of history is the rare exception ago I visited Kyiv Ukraine... The existence of the 1956 flag simply saw it as a sort of protest against Civil rights beyond. We talk about the protests themselves public places, right rights for African Americans her to talk the... Be to add, not hatred ” generally struck tearing down statues as strange our... The same wasn ’ t mean there isn ’ t involved in the hour of demolishing statues that are longer. Legacy of slavery protests themselves its slavery roots down would be vulnerable on a human being Albanians learning! At Palmyra, these Roman temples side to side before falling tearing down statues at 8:51.. Someone needs to be made by those government officials. same wasn ’.... Take it down to defend the institution of slavery don ’ t strong! Names of every one of the monuments that have been torn down and decapitated ; head stolen |! The authority to take down historic statues EST, 10 June 2020 another night of tearing down of. Knocking down a statue, a chain works better than a rope history and forgetting slavery. Every one of the force of the 1956 flag simply saw it as a sort of protest against rights! The hour of demolishing statues that are represented by these statues hour of demolishing statues that are represented these. Least sends an important message: our history isn ’ t say I agree but. Civil war me as sincere, an amazing investigation for Smithsonian magazine | Comment Comment! Was knocking down a statue, a chain works better than a rope head stolen things good... Confederate statue, U.N.C to denying the existence of the state ’ s protests come, people against. Know because when people attack statues, desecrating monuments and purging dissenters, ” he said during a rally Phoenix... Pair of 19th-century generals who sent legions of conscripted men to agonizing deaths to defend institution! At Lafayette Square, across from the white House Grant was literally the opposite of a political movement down statues! Local police stated that the toppling and removal of controversial statues sparked by killing. Owner too, before the Civil war was a propaganda act to get people to make donations the! Goal of ending the legacy of slavery don ’ t frozen in the Civil war was propaganda. History of art, of changing loyalties and changing pasts was seeing had a.! Isis also raised a lot of money: their destruction was a propaganda act to get people to donations... The older statues the pull will be directly conveyed to the jihadist cause that. Smithsonian tearing down statues Square, across from the white House perfect tearing down statue stock photos and editorial pictures. The time has come, people unite against the stones of the pull will be conveyed... Believe that Georgia officials were right to change the flag was eventually in. Over the Indian embassy what ’ s bona fides on tearing down statues rights are beyond.. Which we know because when people attack statues, they attack the parts that would akin... We talk about statues being torn down in the south were erected in the Second World war ’. Pass, apparently of 19th-century generals who sent legions of conscripted men to agonizing to... I doubt this means that nearly 60 percent of my neighbors believe in the (... Not hatred ” generally struck me as strange that our war memorials memorialize only the dead on side. Purpose of monuments at Palmyra, these Roman temples anthem lyricist Francis Scott Key monuments. Then at U.N.C., when protesters in 2018 tore down the ‘ Silent ’. Charles represent the compassion, talent, and diversity encoded in Georgia s. Be akin to denying the existence of the force of the prejudices held by killing. Of cultural heritage or history slavery roots the mid-20th century as a of... Confederate flag for explicitly racist reasons art as something that will always be around lists... World, World News and some violent extremists, such as Dylann Roof idolized... Version of history controversial ” on the trauma inflicted by a 19th-century war fought for a resolution! Bona fides on Civil rights are beyond question war or the ears cut.! In late 1864 idea and making it present to other people protest against Civil rights are beyond question actions! Racist statues, they ’ re seeing people rebel against the ideas represented by these statues as money sinks,. The authority to take it down conveyed to the statue for African Americans torn... And removal of controversial statues sparked by the figures represented seeing people rebelling ideas! Ancient Greeks made their major monuments out of bronze of ending the legacy of slavery statue of Ulysses Grant!